Skip to content
Swiss FolkloreCollected tales · English translations · Reader notes
Swiss Folklore Collection

The Lesser Evil

English translation

Long ago, when a man was to be hanged or executed by the sword and a maiden came forward and offered to marry him, his life was spared provided that he consented to the marriage.

Thus it once happened, when a man already stood on the scaffold, that a Meitli1 judged to be rather pretty stepped forward at the last moment and offered to take the condemned man in marriage. But he looked at her for a moment and then said:

‘Rots Haar, spitzi Nasä2,
Hänker schlach züe,
Besser einisch g'littä,
As hundertmal g'strittä.’
‘Red hair, pointed nose;
hangman, strike away.
Better to suffer once
than quarrel a hundred times.’

Karl Gisler, Schächental

Reader notes

  1. Meitli

    Swiss German for a girl or young woman; here the diminutive identifies the prospective bride in the tale's bluntly comic and historically sexist judgment.

  2. Rots Haar, spitzi Nasä

    the opening of an Uri dialect rhyme meaning ‘Red hair, pointed nose’; the full verse tells the hangman to strike because one execution is better than a hundred quarrels, expressing the condemned man's historically sexist judgment.

Original text

Das kleinere Übel

Vor Zeiten, wenn einer sollte gehängt oder durch das Schwert hingerichtet werden und es kam eine Jungfrau und anerbot sich, ihn zu heiraten, so schenkte man ihm das Leben, sofern er in die Heirat einwilligte.

So geschah es einst, als man Einen auf dem Schaffot hatte, dass ein, wie man urteilte, ziemlich hübsches Meitli im letzten Moment hervortrat und sich anerbot, den Verurteilten zur Ehe zu nehmen. Dieser aber betrachte es einen Augenblick und sagte dann:

»Rots Haar, spitzi Nasä,
Hänker schlach züe,
Besser einisch g'littä,
As hundertmal g'strittä.«

Karl Gisler, Schächental

Story context

Places
Uri
Themes
Courtship and marriage

Discussion

Start a discussion on Mastodon

Webmentions

Reply on your own website and link to this tale. Send a Webmention to let me know. Verified responses from trusted sources appear after the next refresh; other responses are reviewed first.

No approved Webmentions yet.

Your page must contain a link to this tale. Submission queues it for verification and moderation.