Skip to content
Swiss FolkloreCollected tales · English translations · Reader notes
Swiss Folklore Collection

The Promise

English translation

Two young men from Widnau promised each other that whichever of them died first must appear to the other on the threshing floor of the barn and bring definite news about the hereafter. One of them then died, but out of fear the other neglected to seek out the appointed place. When at last, after some time, he did so, the other called his name and asked: "Why did you wait so long?"

The house where this is said to have occurred is very well known to me.
U. Schawalder

The legend springs from the desire of the overly curious to obtain information about the hereafter. But the fact that no departed person has yet returned is proven precisely by the circumstance that none of these legends has anything credible to report about the abode of the blessed and the damned.

Reader notes

  1. About this telling

    The German genre Sage often ties an extraordinary event to a named place, time, or witness. Such details establish the telling’s local authority, but do not independently verify the event. The source credit identifies the recorded version preserved here.

Original text

Das Versprechen

Zwei Widnauer Jünglinge gaben einander das Versprechen, daß derjenige von ihnen, der zuerst sterbe, dem andern auf dem Scheunentenn erscheinen und bestimmte Kunde über das Jenseits bringen müsse. Nun starb der eine; aber der andere unterließ aus Furcht, den bestimmten Ort aufzusuchen. Als es endlich nach einiger Zeit doch geschah, rief der andere seinen Namen und fragte: "Warum hast du auch so lange gewartet?"

Das Haus, wo das vorgefallen sein soll, ist mir sehr gut bekannt.
U. Schawalder

Die Sage entspringt dem Verlangen Vorwitziger, über das Jenseits Aufklärung zu erhalten. Daß aber noch kein Abgeschiedener zurückgekehrt ist, beweist eben der Umstand, daß keine dieser Sagen über den Ort der Seligen und Unseligen etwas Glaubwürdiges zu melden weiß.

Story context

Places
St. Gallen
Themes
Storytelling and belief

Discussion

Start a discussion on Mastodon

Webmentions

Reply on your own website and link to this tale. Send a Webmention to let me know. Verified responses from trusted sources appear after the next refresh; other responses are reviewed first.

No approved Webmentions yet.

Your page must contain a link to this tale. Submission queues it for verification and moderation.